Insurance Agency Google SEO

Three Ways Insurance Agents Can Get Onto Page 1 Of Google

Share this blog:

If you’re an insurance agent, page one Google rankings can seem like an impossible task. Afterall, insurance is the single most competitive category on the internet; more than the 2nd 3rd and 4th combined.

When you’re trying to get onto page one, there are three areas you can focus on:

Organic Search: Organic search is for your website. It is when your site ranks in the normal, not paid and not maps area of search results. It is your website pages that show up here and each of your landing pages should be targeting individual products and keywords to show up here.

For search engine optimization, organic search is a crucial step to compete for your keywords in an environment that is not paid search. Paid search is incredibly effective at driving new business leads, but in our industry, insurance related keywords can be expensive. If you’re trying to target auto & home leads through paid search, you’d better have a healthy budget of $750+ per month for clicks and conversions.

  Local Search: Local search is an under-utilized part of search engine optimization. This is taking your Google My Business listing and optimizing it for search keywords in order to show up in the maps area of Google. By showing up here, you capitalize on any potential customer searching for insurance near you. The reason this is important is that it greatly improves your chances of conversion because it pings the customers IP address then shows your results to them.

For example: If someone is looking for an “Insurance Agent in Seattle” Google will return both organic and local search (Maps) results back to the user. Maps usually is displayed first as Google knows where you’re located.

Insurance Agency Google My Business

Google My Business is just as important as having a website and they speak to one another. In fact, Google will oftentimes display, “Their website mentions motorcycle insurance” or other insurance products because Google keeps all this information on-hand to reference and return relevant search results to the users.

Paid Search: Paid search for insurance agents requires patience and a healthy budget. Because of the way that Google’s algorithm works, ranking on state-level for competitive keywords is highly unlikely. In order to rank highly on the page they want you to pay for those keywords.

Paid Search is effective. It is the only way to have guaranteed page one rankings and that can happen in hours, not months or years like Organic SEO.

When running paid search ads, be sure to highly target your market. We see too many instances where agents target keywords so broadly like “insurance.” This will return irrelevant results and drive up your cost per conversion. It is advised to either take Google Ads training prior to running your own campaigns or hire a Google Ads specialist who understands and works in insurance.

When investing any marketing dollars in SEO, it is important to have reasonable expectations. Unfortunately, page one Google rankings don’t always equal leads. While the most effective strategy is a mix of all the above strategies the best and most important thing to remember about any marketing is to be consistent and keep trying.

Tosten Marketing specializes in Insurance Agency SEO. Our agency was designed from within the insurance agency channel and it is the only customer we market to. We are nationally endorsed by four major insurance carriers for our SEO programs and maintain near perfect customer retention. If you need help with your insurance agency marketing, we can help you design a website, complete your SEO and give you self-help if you like doing things yourself. We offer consultation service to all of our existing customers free of charge.

Google Analytics For Insurance Agents

Tutorial: Google Analytics For Insurance Agents

Google Analytics For Insurance Agents

Google Analytics For Insurance Agents – What to look at and how to utilize the data

It isn’t uncommon for a customer to ask for access to their Google Analytics data. While we are always happy to provide this, having access to your website data is only as good as your understandings of the data. Today I’ll cover the top 5 areas you should familiarize yourself with on your Analytics report.

Acquisition Channels – Where did the site visitor originate?

Understanding how your website is getting traffic is one of the most important parts of marketing your insurance agency website. If you know how people are getting there, it can provide great insights into how your overall marketing campaigns are performing.

Acquisition channels are broken up into 6 main categories.

  1. Organic Search – This is where your SEO campaign shines. Is your website getting organic traffic? This means you showed up in search results as a result to a search in Google or Bing and the visitor clicked through to your site.
  2. Direct Traffic – Direct traffic is when someone goes directly to your website. For instance, if you’re looking for Tosten Marketing and you just type in: into a search browser.
  3. Display – Paid search traffic that gets visitors to your site by displaying an advertisement on another site. Banner ads and image ads are the most common display ads.
  4. Referral Traffic – When someone is browsing another website and sees a link to your site embedded in an article or in a listing such as a directory listing.
  5. Paid Search – Traffic to your site that is generated by running paid ads in search engines such as Google and Bing.
  6. Social – Traffic to your site that came from a social media platform like Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter.

Insurance Agency Google Analytics

How to see your acquisition channels:

From your main dashboard on the left hand side, navigate to Acquisition -> All Traffic -> Channels.

Audience Location – Where are the people physically located who visit your site?

Over the years I’ve worked with hundreds of insurance agencies. Most I’d say only look at a number in their analytics for how many people visited their website. The more important question than how many is where.

For example. If you’re a licensed independent insurance agent in Texas, getting traffic from Canada, India and Japan really doesn’t do your website any good.

If your marketing is working correctly, you should get the bulk of your website traffic from the United States and furthermore, from the state that you have a physical presence in.

Identifying your audience location can be a great sign that your SEO and other digital marketing is working correctly. If you’re seeing a lot of traffic from other countries you’ll want to identify why. Perhaps you have a paid search campaign that isn’t properly setup, or it could even be a good indicator that you site may have malware.

Audience Location Google Analytics

How to see your Audience Location:

From the main dashboard on the left hand side, navigate to: Audience -> Geo -> Location (then if you want more specific state data, click on United States).


Audience Device – What type device did the visitor browse your site from?: Desktop, Mobile or Tablet


The importance of understanding what type of device the user visited your website with is important for a few reasons.

You can measure time on site and abandon rate variances between devices. Knowing this can help you identify opportunities such as improving bounce rate or time on site. For instance, if you see mobile has a high abandon rate, it may be because your site loads slowly or displays poorly on a mobile device.

Device Usage Google Analytics

How to see your Device Usage Type:

From the main dashboard on the left hand side, navigate to: Audience -> Mobile -> Overview

Site Content Overview: What pages did the user look at on your site?

Understanding what content on your site people visited can give you great insights into where your site is performing well or understanding where it is performing poorly. However, low traffic doesn’t always indicate poor performance – it may simply indicate low search volumes.

For instance, if the auto insurance page of your website has 100 visitors a month and your funeral home insurance page of your website has 2 visitors, it is likely because not many people are searching for “funeral home insurance.”

By understanding what content on your website is performing well and what content might be standing out can give you rich insights to do more targeted content around that topic that is driving traffic to your site.

How to identify Site Content

From the main dashboard on the left hand side, navigate to: Behavior -> Site Content -> All Pages

Site Speed Suggestions: How quickly is your site loading and what can be done to improve?

Because speed is an SEO factor it is important to pay attention to a slow loading website. Google Analytics gives free insight and scores each of your pages with a PageSpeed score. This quick look can help you identify issues with your site and work with your website developer to improve these metrics.

For page speed, aim for a score of 80+. Perfection is impossible so a score of 80 or higher is a good goal.

Website Page Speed Analytics

How to view your Page Speed

From the main dashboard on the left hand side, navigate to: Behavior -> Site Speed -> Speed Suggestions.

Understanding these Google Analytics measurements will not only help you understand how your site is performing, but can help you identify issues with the site, issues with your digital marketing or areas in which you can simply improve upon. Ultimately you don’t need to spend too much time overanalyzing your reports. If you’re overwhelmed, a website audit can help identify areas of opportunity.

We hope you’ve found this post on Understanding Your Insurance Agency Website Google Analytics Reports helpful. By paying attention to these reports, you can continue to improve your website with the tools that the search engines give you.

What to Do When Insurance Quotes Are Slow For Your Insurance Agency

When New Business Quotes Are Slow, Shift The Focus To Your Existing Book Of Business

Share this blog:

What to Do When Insurance Quotes Are Slow For Your Insurance AgencyFor some reason or another, insurance has slow periods. Whether this is during the holidays, or simply on and off during the month, insurance quotes and new business seem to come in chunks. We can’t explain it, but perhaps someone at Google could let us in on the secret.

Until you break the algorithm code, when it gets slow one thing every insurance agency should be doing is focusing on retention and cross-selling their book.

Perhaps you got busy and your agents didn’t cross-sell everyone they could. Perhaps you were short staffed and just wrote the customers requested policy. Regardless of what occurs in your office, there are things you can do. Here are some suggestions:

  1. Revisit business quoted and review every policy written in the last month
    • If you didn’t write someone, review it and see why. Perhaps a simple phone call can generate the business.
    • Set a reminder to follow up with that lead in 5 months to see if you can requote them. Perhaps they now have prior insurance or a ticket or accident fell off the record.
  2. Create and send out a newsletter to your existing clients
    • Newsletters are invaluable when it comes to retaining your clients. Every agent should be trying to touch base with their clients at minimum 5 times per year. Newsletters can quickly be created in systems like MailChimp or Constant Contact. Share some agency news, some personal agent news and mention some cross sell pieces like umbrella or talk about a hot topic like Rideshare Insurance
  3. Policy Reviews
    • I love it when my agent calls us to review our policy every year. It shows me that they care and they check in to see if anything changed. It is also a great opportunity to mention your referral program or to ask them to like your social media pages.
  4. Look for Low-Hanging Fruit
    • If you have an agency management system, run a report for monoline home or renters insurance.
    • Run a report for monoline motorcycle insurance. Did you know that over 50% of motorcycle owners are homeowners?
    • Cross-sell umbrella to your high limit homeowners.

There are many things you can do when it gets slow at your agency. Working your existing book of business is the simplest way to generate new policies and make more money when things are slow. Don’t sit there waiting for the phone to ring when you already likely have more leads than you could possibly work that are already your customers.

Insurance Agency Review Online

Utilize Online Reviews to Grow Your Insurance Agency

Share this blog:

Agents often ask, “What else can we be doing online to continue improving results?” The answer is simpler than most think: Online Reviews are more and more important in the search engine optimization (SEO) ecosystem. Soliciting reviews from your customers is not only imperative, but in my opinion one of the best ways agents are currently utilizing their staff and their own time.

How do I get Reviews Online?

To increase your reviews online you have to ask. If you don’t ask, you simply won’t get them. Agents who implement this into their daily strategy are benefitting now and will continue to lead other agencies including yours if you don’t begin using this free tool.

You employ great agents and you’re a great business owner yourself. We know time is limited at your agency, but during all policies being issues over the phone, taking payments, or while sending out the application to the client via email, you should be asking for a review. It only takes a second to ask!

Make it Easy for Clients to Review Your Business

Two of the best ways to easily get reviews from clients are also some of the easiest to implement.

  1. Your email signature: Add something along the lines of “Happy with our service, please LEAVE US A REVIEW” to your email signature. This way, they have the link every single time receive an email from you.
  2. Have your web developer add a page on your website dedicated to reviews and add buttons to the different platforms for reviews so all your clients have to do is click which one is best for them. Take the below example:

Agents that have reviews on Google, Facebook or Yelp, simply rank higher for local search. If you want to grow your business online you need to implement this strategy today! If we manage your agency marketing, we do our best to solicit reviews in newsletters, social media and on your website. By requiring you’re to add the small extra comment, “Would you mind leaving us a review? I will send you the link!” to every phone call!

Tosten Marketing is an insurance agency marketing company specializing in fully automated marketing programs that include website design, search engine optimization (SEO), insurance agency newsletters and more! We are endorsed by leading insurance carriers and help agents across the country manage marketing campaigns. If you’re interested in learning more about Tosten Marketing or getting in touch visit us online at

Every Business Logo Should Have Meaning

Share this blog:

Tosten Marketing GearsI can admit it: We’ve had a bit of a personality conflict internally about what our logo should represent. I’ve always told clients that their logo should be able to speak for itself, but this is something we ourselves have struggled to portray.

So, let me give you a little background about where this all originated from: Since I was a little kid I’ve always been infatuated with the way mechanical objects work. I once took apart an old pocket watch and removed all of the gears because I was curious how it worked. It was amazing to me how all of the tiny, delicate cogs worked together to run a hand that was so much larger and heavier.

As a journalism student at Western Washington University I had the opportunity to interview and write a story that was published in a magazine called Klipsun about a local artist named Kathy Bastow. Kathy was way ahead of the Steampunk movement and reused old gears, bolts and even metalic odds and ends to make incredible lamps and clocks. What struck me at this time was these gears were being used for a greater good to create something from individual pieces that by themselves did nothing, but together created beautiful pieces of art.

Their websites should act as the driving engine while their newsletters, blogs and social media should be the gears that run together to establish the final product – turn the hands of the clock if you will.

As I pondered what we should do with our logo, I wanted it to be meaningful and send a message about our program and processes. That always brought me back to gears or cogs and how they all worked together towards a greater good. None of the pieces individually do much, but when they’re combined, they can make incredibly precise instruments.

When looking at our business and think about our message, we explain to customers almost on a daily basis that their marketing campaigns should work like fine-tuned gears running together in unison. Their websites should act as the driving engine while their newsletters, blogs and social media should be the gears that run together to establish the final product – turn the hands of the clock if you will. Since the beginning, we’ve believed that to be successful at marketing an insurance agency, you can’t do just one thing; you must do  multiple things that run together in harmony. This always brings me back to the industrial image of relating insurance marketing to gears and cogs.

We know logos may not be that important to some, but for us, we’ve finally found one that makes sense for our business and that we feel cannot only stand the test of time, but stand alone by itself to explain our ideology as a company.